• Latest
Supreme Court Remands Case Concerning Christian Postman

Supreme Court Remands Case Concerning Christian Postman

July 10, 2023
Dodgers Pitcher Clayton Kershaw Displays Bible Verse on Hat During Pride Night

Dodgers Pitcher Clayton Kershaw Displays Bible Verse on Hat During Pride Night

June 17, 2025
Ken Ham: French Scientist Baulieu ‘Made the World a Much More Dangerous Place’

Ken Ham: French Scientist Baulieu ‘Made the World a Much More Dangerous Place’

June 13, 2025
Vinton County Residents Evacuated After Chemical Leak at Ohio Manufacturing Plant

Vinton County Residents Evacuated After Chemical Leak at Ohio Manufacturing Plant

June 12, 2025
Texas Governor Greg Abbott Deploys National Guard Amid Planned Immigration Protests

Texas Governor Greg Abbott Deploys National Guard Amid Planned Immigration Protests

June 11, 2025
Newsom: Secretary of Defense Is ‘Illegally Deploying’ Troops Amidst LA Protests

Newsom: Secretary of Defense Is ‘Illegally Deploying’ Troops Amidst LA Protests

June 10, 2025
Podcast – Lititz Pride Fest, Dinosaurs, and a New Cell Phone Law

Podcast – Lititz Pride Fest, Dinosaurs, and a New Cell Phone Law

June 9, 2025
Paul Miller’s Law Takes Effect in Pennsylvania, Banning Handheld Cellphone Use While Driving

Paul Miller’s Law Takes Effect in Pennsylvania, Banning Handheld Cellphone Use While Driving

June 6, 2025
N.T. Wright: Abortion Done ‘As Soon As Possible’ Is Okay for ‘Certain Exceptions’

N.T. Wright: Abortion Done ‘As Soon As Possible’ Is Okay for ‘Certain Exceptions’

June 5, 2025
Spencer: Neo-Nazi Ideology a ‘Far More Pernicious Threat’ Than Internet Porn

Spencer: Neo-Nazi Ideology a ‘Far More Pernicious Threat’ Than Internet Porn

June 5, 2025
Musk: Trump’s Spending Bill a ‘Disgusting Abomination’

Musk: Trump’s Spending Bill a ‘Disgusting Abomination’

June 4, 2025
Sicily’s Mount Etna Erupts with Ash Plumes; Officials Confirm No Threat to Population

Sicily’s Mount Etna Erupts with Ash Plumes; Officials Confirm No Threat to Population

June 2, 2025
Body of Missing Pennsylvania Park Ranger Recovered After Kayak Incident

Body of Missing Pennsylvania Park Ranger Recovered After Kayak Incident

May 27, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Sunday, July 6, 2025
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Lancaster Patriot
No Result
View All Result
  • Lancaster News
  • National News
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Future of Christendom
  • Lancaster News
  • National News
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Future of Christendom
No Result
View All Result
The Lancaster Patriot
No Result
View All Result
Home Lancaster News

Supreme Court Remands Case Concerning Christian Postman

by The Lancaster Patriot Staff
July 10, 2023
in Lancaster News
0
Supreme Court Remands Case Concerning Christian Postman

Gerald Groff speaks with First Liberty Live after the recent Supreme Court ruling. (YouTube/First Liberty Institute)

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Supreme Court vacated and remanded the case of Gerald Groff, the former Lancaster County postal service worker who refused to work on Sundays, thus sending the case back to lower courts.

Though Groff’s overall case is not over, the Supreme Court decision is considered a victory for Groff, as the ruling potentially makes it harder for employers to dismiss religious requests.

While working for the United States Postal Service (USPS) in Lancaster County, Groff faced the challenge of working on Sundays when USPS began facilitating Sunday deliveries for Amazon. To avoid the Sunday work requirement, Groff transferred to a rural route without Sunday deliveries.

However, when Amazon deliveries began at the rural station, Groff remained unwilling to labor on Sunday. Eventually, Groff received “progressive discipline” for failing to work on Sundays, and he resigned in 2018.

Groff then sued the postal service under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, asserting that USPS could have accommodated his request to not work on Sundays “without undue hardship on the conduct of [USPS’s] business.”

Lower courts ruled against Groff and in favor of USPS, with the Third Circuit finding that exempting Groff from Sunday work had “imposed on his coworkers, disrupted the workplace and workflow, and diminished employee morale.”

On June 29, the Supreme Court vacated the decision of lower courts and remanded the case, sending it back to lower courts to reconsider Groff’s suit based on the higher court’s understanding of the facts of the case.

The issue of requesting certain days off for religious beliefs is not novel in American courts. A Supreme Court case in 1977 (Hardison v. Trans World Airlines) found that the airline was not required to violate its seniority system to make the requested accommodation for Hardison, who requested to not work Saturdays due to religious beliefs.

In a syllabus issued by the Supreme Court in the Groff case, the Court said it “understands Hardison to mean that ‘undue hardship’ is shown when a burden is substantial in the overall context of an employer’s business.”

The Court ruled that “‘undue hardship’ means something very different from a burden that is merely more than de minimis, i.e., ‘very small or trifling.’”  The Court referenced Hardison and noted that “substantial additional costs” or “substantial expenditures” would need to be present for the hardship to be considered “undue.”

The ruling effectively sets aside the “de minimis” standard set more than 45 years ago, thus requiring employers to demonstrate not simply “minimal” hardship, but substantial hardship in denying religious accommodations.

Justice Alito delivered the opinion for the unanimous Court, saying that their ruling clarifies “the Title VII undue-hardship standard” and thus gives the lower courts a “clarified standard” to apply in the Groff case.

“Without foreclosing the possibility that USPS will prevail, we think it appropriate to leave it to the lower courts to apply our clarified context-specific standard, and to decide whether any further factual development is needed,” Alito wrote.

For a lower court to rule against Groff, it will need to be demonstrated that Groff’s request placed “substantial” hardship on his employer, not merely a “very small” hardship.

“I hope this decision allows others to be able to maintain their convictions without living in fear of losing their jobs because of what they believe,” Groff said in a statement following the ruling.

Kelly Shackelford, Chief Counsel with First Liberty Institute, called the ruling “a major win” and a “total shift in the landscape in the workplace,” adding that the “standard has been wrong” for 46 years.

“Every person of faith who works in the country that lost their protection – by Gerald being faithful, God has used this to restore that to everybody who works across the country,” Shackelford said. “This is really significant.”

The American Postal Workers Union, however, issued a brief to the court stating that a ruling in favor of Groff would create a “religious preference” for scheduling work on the weekend – something that could disadvantage other workers who do not share the same religious beliefs.

In a statement from Postal Service spokeswoman Felicia Lott issued after the ruling, Lott said she expects USPS to win the case, even with the clarifications from the Supreme Court.

Tags: gerald groffusps
Next Post
Answers in Genesis CEO Ken Ham Calls Out Apologist for ‘Undermining the Authority of Scripture’

Answers in Genesis CEO Ken Ham Calls Out Apologist for ‘Undermining the Authority of Scripture’

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

The Illegitimacy of Eminent Domain

The Illegitimacy of Eminent Domain

3 years ago
Wildfire Risk for Region on Monday

Wildfire Risk for Region on Monday

2 years ago

Popular Content

  • Officer Named in Damon Atkins Lawsuit Found Dead

    Officer Named in Damon Atkins Lawsuit Found Dead

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘David’ Premieres at Sight & Sound Theaters

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New Fox Meadows Creamery Location Opens in Leola

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Podcast – Immigration and the American Dream

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Canadian Gender ‘Equity’ Fire Training Program Leads to Out-of-Control Blaze

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Connect with us

facebook instagram gab telegram mewe

Newsletter

STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH OUR E-MAIL NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to our mailing list and receive updates direct to your inbox!

Category

  • Faith
  • Lancaster News
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Media
  • National News
  • PA News
  • Perspectives
  • World News

Site Links

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

About Us

The Lancaster Patriot and The Lancaster Patriot Podcast exist to provide a platform for biblical commentary on current events and robust discussion on the topics that matter most.

  • Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Notices

Copyright © 2022 The Lancaster Patriot

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Lancaster News
  • National News
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Future of Christendom

Copyright © 2022 The Lancaster Patriot